Mental Health Claims Cost 5X More Than Burns: The Hidden Workers Comp Tsunami

(image thanks Goodman Fielder)

The Australian hospitality industry faces a mental health crisis that's reshaping the workers compensation landscape. While a typical burn injury claim costs employers $14,400, psychological injuries now average $65,400: more than four times higher, according to Safe Work Australia's 2024 data. For NSW employers, the situation is even more stark: mental health claims have doubled from $146,000 to $288,542 between 2019 and 2025.

This isn't just about money – it's about people. Hospitality workers experiencing psychological injuries face recovery periods of 37 weeks, compared to just 7.2 weeks for physical injuries. That's nine months away from work, compared to less than two months for a burn or cut.

The Perfect Storm: Why Hospitality Is Ground Zero

The accommodation and food services sector presents a troubling picture. Recent research reveals that 61% of South Australian hospitality workers reported experiencing a mental health condition in the past 12 months: more than double the general population rate. Nationally, 44% of hospitality workers say their job negatively impacts their mental health, with one in three experiencing high to severe psychological distress – double the national average.

What's driving this crisis? The industry's unique pressures create a perfect storm:

• Customer abuse and violence: In clubs and pubs, mental stress claims from workplace violence reach 7-8% of all serious claims (double the industry average)
• Unpredictable rosters and insecure work: Constant schedule changes prevent workers from maintaining work-life balance
• Chronic understaffing: Leading to excessive shifts and burnout becoming normalised
• "Push through" culture: Where mental health struggles are seen as weakness rather than legitimate workplace injuries

Young workers aged 18-24 face the highest risk, entering an industry where high turnover (50-70% annually) is accepted as normal rather than addressed as a symptom of systemic problems.

The Financial Tsunami: Understanding the True Cost

Mental health claims have surged 97% over the past decade, now representing 10.5-12% of all serious workers compensation claims nationally. In 2023-24, this translated to approximately 14,600-17,600 claims across Australia. The economic impact extends far beyond direct compensation costs:

• National cost: Approximately $543 million paid annually in workers compensation for work-related mental health conditions
• NSW alone: Psychologically unsafe workplaces cost an estimated $2.8 billion annually
• Hidden costs: Reduced productivity, increased absenteeism, recruitment and training expenses

Yet these figures likely underrepresent the true scale. Workers compensation data for psychological injuries in hospitality typically accounts for less than 1% of accepted claims in the sector, despite mental health conditions representing nearly 10% across all industries. Fear of job loss, stigma, and lack of awareness keep vulnerable workers from claiming their rights.

The Three Culprits: What's Causing the Crisis

Safe Work Australia's data identifies three primary causes of mental health workers compensation claims:

1. Harassment and bullying (27.5% of claims): The hospitality industry scores notably low on formal anti-bullying policies, despite high safety culture indicators in other areas.
2. Work pressure (25.2% of claims): High emotional job demands combined with low job control and inadequate staffing during peak periods create unsustainable stress levels.
3. Workplace violence (16.4% of claims): Food service workers frequently experience abuse from intoxicated or difficult customers, often dismissed as "just part of the job."

Prevention That Pays: Evidence-Based Solutions

The good news? Prevention works – and it pays. Research demonstrates that for every dollar spent on workplace mental health initiatives, employers receive an average return of $2.30 through increased productivity, reduced turnover, and fewer compensation claims. Some studies report returns as high as $5.70 per dollar invested.

1. Implement Recognition and Reward Systems

O.C. Tanner Institute research demonstrates that positive reinforcement programs can deliver remarkable results:

• 57% reduction in burnout odds for employees who gave recognition in the past 30 days
• 24% decrease in probable anxiety diagnosis
• 28% reduction in probable depression diagnosis

McDonald's franchisees are now in the early stages of implementing workplace recognition systems through platforms like Scratchie, showing promising early signs of engagement across their restaurants. The key to these programs? Making recognition immediate, specific, and tied to meaningful behaviours rather than generic praise. Early adopters focus on recognising customer service excellence, food safety compliance, and cleanliness standards; addressing operational needs while building positive workplace culture.

2. Address Psychosocial Hazards Systematically

Since 2022, Safe Work Australia's Code of Practice requires employers to manage psychosocial hazards with the same rigour as physical risks:

• Conduct regular psychosocial risk assessments using validated tools
• Implement work design improvements: adequate staffing, fair rostering, clear role definitions
• Create psychological safety through open communication channels where workers can report concerns without fear

3. Invest in Manager Training

Research shows that manager behaviour is the single biggest predictor of team mental health. Training should cover:

• Mental health literacy and early warning signs
• How to have supportive conversations
• Legal obligations under WHS legislation
• Creating psychologically safe team environments

Australian studies with apprentice chefs showed that just 3 hours of targeted training improved workers' ability to discuss workplace issues with managers and cope with verbal abuse.

4. Deploy Early Intervention Programs

Employee Assistance Programs (EAPs) show 84% effectiveness in resolving presenting issues when properly implemented. However, traditional uptake remains low at 6%. Alternative models achieving 40% utilisation rates share common features:

• Proactive outreach rather than passive availability
• Integration with workplace culture initiatives
• Tailored services matching workforce demographics
• Visible management support and participation

Scratchie is releasing its EAP component in late 2025 as a free upgrade for all enterprise subscribers. Scratchie's EAP takeup is next level, given almost every worker voluntarily has Scratchie on their device – check the five star reviews in the app stores for proof.

5. Transform Workplace Culture

The National Mental Health Commission's Blueprint recommends a three-pillar approach:

• Protect: Prevent mental health risks through compliance, proactive hazard management, and systematic anti-bullying measures
• Respond: Recognise early signs through education, provide suitable duties and adjustments, support return-to-work
• Promote: Enhance positive mental health through development opportunities, meaningful connections, and recognition of positive behaviours

Implementation Roadmap: Making Change Happen

Phase 1: Assessment and Planning (Weeks 1-4)

• Conduct baseline mental health assessment using People at Work survey
• Review current claims data and identify patterns
• Establish mental health committee with worker representation
• Set measurable targets for improvement

Phase 2: Foundation Building (Weeks 5-12)

• Launch manager mental health training program
• Implement formal anti-bullying and harassment policies
• Introduce recognition system pilot in high-risk areas
• Establish clear reporting channels for psychological hazards

Phase 3: Systematic Implementation (Weeks 13-26)

• Roll out recognition program across all teams
• Deploy EAP with proactive engagement strategy
• Implement work design improvements (rostering, staffing levels)
• Launch peer support networks

Phase 4: Embed and Sustain (Ongoing)

• Regular psychosocial risk assessments
• Monthly mental health metrics review
• Quarterly culture surveys
• Annual program effectiveness evaluation

The Business Case: Why Action Can't Wait

With mental health claims rising 30% in NSW alone between 2018-2023 and showing no signs of slowing, the question isn't whether to act, but how quickly you can implement prevention strategies. Consider:

• A single psychological injury claim costs the equivalent of 4-5 physical injury claims
• Recovery times mean losing experienced workers for nine months on average
• In an industry with 50-70% annual turnover, mental health is often the hidden driver
• Competitors implementing prevention programs gain significant recruitment advantages

More importantly, there's a moral imperative. Behind every statistic is a person—someone's partner, parent, or child—whose life has been fundamentally disrupted by preventable workplace psychological injury.

Conclusion: From Crisis to Opportunity

The mental health claims tsunami in hospitality isn't inevitable. It's the predictable result of systemic workplace factors that can be addressed through evidence-based interventions. While the statistics are sobering – mental health claims costing five times more than burns, affecting one in three workers with psychological distress – the solutions are clear and achievable.

Forward-thinking hospitality operators are already proving that positive workplace cultures aren't just nice to have; they're essential for survival in an industry facing workforce shortages and rising insurance costs. By implementing recognition systems, addressing psychosocial hazards, and building supportive cultures, they're not just reducing claims; they're creating workplaces where people want to work.

The choice is stark: continue accepting mental health claims as a cost of doing business in hospitality, or take action now to prevent them. With returns of $2.30 for every dollar invested in prevention, the business case is clear. The human case is even clearer.

‍